Shaft sub-assembly line for O-ring and bearing installation

Shaft Seal Leaking Again? Check Case Drain Back Pressure First

Field Note Failure & Maintenance

Shaft seal leaking again?
Check the drain line first.

Repeated shaft seal leaks often trace back to case drain back pressure, not to the seal. What to check before replacing it again.

Shaft sub-assembly line for O-ring and bearing installation
Shaft sub-assembly in the THOTH Ningbo plant.

The motor passed its factory test and ran well on the bench. A few hundred hours into field service, oil appears around the output shaft. The seal is replaced, and a few weeks later it leaks again. In many of these cases the seal is not the root cause. The pressure behind it is.

01Mechanism

Why back pressure reaches the shaft seal

Every hydraulic motor has some internal leakage by design, and that oil has to leave the housing. On motors with a case drain port, the drain gives it a low-pressure path back to tank. If the drain line is restricted, or teed into a return line that carries pressure under load, housing pressure rises and acts directly on the shaft seal.

Brendan Casey describes the consequence in Machinery Lubrication: high case pressure places an excessive load on the seal lip, which can wear a groove into the shaft and lead to leakage, and if case pressure exceeds the seal’s design limit the failure can be instantaneous. The same article reports a winch motor case in which a drain routed through the return filter was the likely cause.[1]

02Field check

Check the installation before replacing the seal again

  1. Find the allowable back pressure for the exact motor model in its catalog. Limits differ by design and seal type, so a value from another motor does not transfer.
  2. Trace the drain line. Does it go directly to tank, or into the return line, a filter or a cooler?
  3. Measure housing or drain pressure under real conditions, including cold start and peak return flow.
  4. Look at the removed seal and shaft. A groove under the seal lip points to sustained pressure rather than a one-off defect.
03Design option

When a drain line is not needed

Some orbital motor designs avoid the problem at the source. The THOTH TMPH uses two internal check valves, so no case drain connection is needed.[2] For motors that do have a drain port, the catalog drawing and installation notes for that model are the reference for how it should be connected.

Takeaway

If the same seal fails twice, measure the pressure behind it before ordering a third.

04FAQ

Common questions

Can I connect the case drain to the return line?
Only if the return line pressure, including spikes and cold-start conditions, stays below the allowable back pressure for that motor. Routing the drain directly to tank removes the question.
Should the case drain be filtered?
Filters add back pressure, which is the problem described here. The referenced article recommends against filters on case drain lines in general and explains the precautions if one is used.
Talk to the engineers

Same seal, failing again?

Send us the motor model, the circuit around it and the pressure readings. We will help find the cause before the next replacement.

Email sales20@zihyd.com →Discuss on LinkedIn →
References
  1. [1]B. Casey, “Hydraulic Pump and Motor Case Drains: Should You Filter?”, Machinery Lubrication. machinerylubrication.com
  2. [2]THOTH / ZiHYD, Orbital Motor Catalog, March 2026. TMPH series characteristics.